[Stuff We Don't Agree On]


[Main Page][Class-related Issues][Registries][Miscellaneous][FAQ]


Class-related Issues


Age of the Nebula-class

by "Hobbes"

Mike Okuda states that registries are semi-chronological which could serve as a base to judge the age of Nebula-class starships. Most of the Nebula-class registries are in the 60000 range, while Galaxy-class ships have registries in the 71000 range. Adhering to that idea, a class ship's registry will necessarily precede all other registries in the class. Therefore, the USS Nebula's registry number is lower than 60205 (the USS Honshu, the lowest registry known). Since this is 10,432 lower than the USS Galaxy's registry, NCC-70637, it is almost indisputable that the Nebula-class came first.

Another supporting argument is the computer system onboard Nebula-class ships. The aft computer station on the USS Sutherland seen in "Redemption, Part II" has an older look, like the LCARS interface on Ambassador-class ships; which we all know for a fact is older than the Galaxy-class. Though the USS Sutherland also has the highest registry for a Nebula-class ship known, NCC-72015. Also the USS Sutherland was launched on stardate 44820.5, which is the year 2368 (The Next Generation's 4th season).

Okay, the Nebula-class was built first, but was the Galaxy-class designed first? Registries are considered to be given when a starship is ordered, so even before the actual construction of the ship starts it will have a registry, but not a name. The Galaxy-class may have been on the drawing board first. About the time the Galaxy-class was being developed the Federation was at war with Cardassia. There was an impossible need to build the ship faster, so they made a smaller new design based on the Galaxy-class and called it the Nebula-class. If Starfleet were designing a ship that would be the flagship class of the Federation they would want to base it on something that already works. Another point is that while designing the Nebula-class Starfleet might of wondered if they took the components of 12 Nebula-class ships and did this to them, creating an advanced or even super Nebula-class as it were that eventually became known as the Galaxy-class. If this theory holds up, then reason the Nebula-class was produced first was because the need for advanced ships during the Cardassian War. They are smaller, making for less construction time and could be built faster than the Galaxy-class. The Nebula-class also might have been built to replace older Starfleet vessels like the Excelsior and Miranda-class. Its design suggests it could fill the role of both classes.

The Nebula-class is certainly not newer than the Galaxy-class, and it's probably older. However, points has been brought up that suggest both classes were designed at the same time, but the Nebula-class was produced first. The Galaxy-class is a much larger more advanced ship that would require more construction time than the Nebula-class.


Age of the Prometheus-class

by Justin Moody

When "Message in a Bottle" (VOY) aired, we were introduced to the ultra-sophisticated USS Prometheus. However, a problem instantly emerged. Another ship named Prometheus, this one Nebula Class appeared in "Second Sight" (DS9), where it played host to Professor Gideon Seyetik. Since it's rather obvious that a) two ships in active service cannot have the same name and that b) a technological "wundervessel" like the Prometheus couldn't have been constructed in the period between Season 2 of DS9 and Season 4 of Voyager, we are left in a dilemma.

There are a few explanations: First, that the Nebula-class Prometheus was allowed to be named such in order to cover the existence of the Prometheus-class Prometheus. Second, that the Nebula Class Prometheus had been destroyed or decommissioned and that the Prometheus Class Prometheus was named in honor of the vessel. This second explanation draws much flak, as it is mistakenly believed that even if the name had been changed that the class would still bear the "old" name. This is untrue, as the rules of naming ships, based on current naval rules dictate that if a ship's name is changed PRIOR to commissioning, the name of the class changes as well - for real life examples, simply look at the name of the Russian aircraft carrier. Originally named 'Riga,' the Kuznetsov had her name changed later to 'Leonid Brezhnev,' and later 'Tbilisi' before her name was finally changed to Kuznetsov. With each name change, the class's name was changed as well. Note, however, that this is true only for ships that have not been commissioned yet - each of the Russian Kirov Class Battlecruisers, including the lead ship, had their names changed, however the class still remains named "Kirov."

So how then, would the Prometheus not have been in commissioned at the time of this conjectured destruction/decommissioning of her Nebula-class predecessor? One needs to look no further than the registry number of the Prometheus: NX-59650. For a supposedly modern ship, this number seems ridiculously low. In fact, assuming registries are chronological, this number makes the Prometheus older than the Nebula-class, which it clearly is superior to. Once again, how to explain this? The most plausible explanation is that work was begun on the Prometheus at a rather early rate in time, perhaps to her current specifications, perhaps not. However, at some point, work was stopped on the yet unnamed hulk and she was placed into storage. Later, possibly shortly after the Battle of Wolf 359, Starfleet reexamined the possibilities of the Prometheus-class (which, perhaps for security reasons, still did not have a name, merely a registration number) and hauled it out of storage, working on it in secret. Finally, sometime after the Nebula-class Prometheus was destroyed/decommissioned, the lead ship was formally named Prometheus in honor of its predecessor. Commissioned, she went into service, where she had her meeting with fate and helped solve the mystery of what had happened to the USS Voyager.


Antares-class

by Bernd Schneider

The name Antares for a starship was first used in the TOS episode "Charlie X", but screen evidence is missing and the registry remains unknown for the next 25 years. It is questionable if the NCC-501 given in the Star Trek Encyclopedia was actually supposed to be the Antares' registry in the old TOS script.

In TNG Antares-class ships are frequently used by civilian (human and alien) owners. There is plenty of screen evidence for the boxy design of this type of cargo ship. The most prominent ships of are the Batris (TNG: "Heart of Glory") and the Bajoran freighter that doesn't even have warp propulsion (TNG: "Ensign Ro"). Starfleet, however, also has an Antares-class as of 2368. The USS Hermes NCC-10376 is the only known ship of this class, and it could not be identified on screen, but was only listed with its name and registry. The Star Trek Encyclopedia suggests that the old TOS Antares is the class ship, although this does not read imperative.

Two questions arise:

  1. Is the at least 100 years old Antares actually the class ship for a Starfleet class still in use in the times of TNG?
  2. Does Starfleet actually employ chunky low-performance starships that don't look like Starfleet ships at all?

Solutions:

  • The old TOS Antares is actually the class ship for the TNG Antares-class. The design has probably been upgraded several times. It's similar as with the Miranda-class which is not much newer. The alien Antares-class ships are completely different designs, since Starfleet wouldn't share modern technology with whoever requires a cargo ship. Solution A would cover all evidence, provided that Starfleet does use other class designations than civilians do. Still, many people don't like the unnecessary connection between the old and new Starfleet Antares (class) in the Encyclopedia.
  • The old Antares is not the class ship of the Starfleet class of the 24th century, and it's no class ship at all. The new Antares-class might have been named in honor of the destroyed ship, though. The alien Antares-class might be anything else. This solution is favored by those who don't trust in Okuda's possibly arbitrary numbering and classifying of ships in the Encyclopedia.
  • The old USS Antares is the same as the alien Antares-class, which is corroborated by an according hint in the Encyclopedia ("We wonder if this might be what the ship in 'Charlie X' (TOS) looks like"). If, however, these ships are the same class and are both Antares-class, how can the name be re-used for the new Antares-class, unless this is also the same design?
  • The TNG Starfleet Antares-class and the contemporary alien/civilian class of this name are actually identical. This leaves the possibility open that even the TOS Antares is of this design. Although this solution avoids the naming conflict, it is unlikely that either Starfleet shares their technology with potential enemies or Starfleet uses totally obsolete ships in a battle (TNG: "Redemption").


Challenger, Springfield, Korolev, and Whorfin Class Ships

by Bernd Schneider

The USS Challenger (NCC-2032), USS Springfield (NCC-1963), USS Korolev (NCC-2014), and USS Whorfin (NCC-1024) were listed on displays in "Star Trek: The Undiscovered Country". It is a common suggestion that these three ships are the class ships of Challenger-, Springfield- and Whorfin-class, respectively.

Challenger: The Challenger-class USS Buran NCC-57580 at Wolf 359 is supposed to be a modified Constitution-class with nacelles directly attached to the saucer rear-end. The appearance of Constitution engineering hull debris in "Best of Both Worlds" (TNG) seems to confirm this. The registries of all three known ships, however, are in the 57xxx range. So, the design is probably much newer than the old USS Challenger, unless a complicated theory is created to explain the use of a very old design for ships with new numbers.

Springfield: There is no design for this class, although the class was present at Wolf 359, so it could be any of the study models for the Excelsior or the Phase II Enterprise, for instance, which were all used for the graveyard scenes. The registries are the only evidence, and they suggest the ship from the 2280's is probably not the class ship for the USS Chekov, with it's NCC-53702 registry.

Korolev: Basically the same argument (registry too high) as for the Springfield, except that there is almost definitely no studio model for this class.

Whorfin: The two transport ships from Star Trek: Generations are Whorfin-class ships. Since they are contemporary to the USS Whorfin featured a few years before in the real and Trek timeline, this is probably the class ship. Otherwise the class ship must have been decommissioned or destroyed before its time, which is (hopefully) not the normal case, or the Whorfin class must be brand new at the time of Generations, which is improbable because of the diverging registries. On the other hand, since the two ships in Generations were civilian ships, there's no reason to believe Starfleet even has a Whorfin-class.


Constitution Class Ship

by Tim Nix

According to a computer readout in "Space Seed" (TOS) the USS Constitution has a registry of NCC-1700. However, the USS Constellation and USS Republic were seen on screen as Constitution-class ships with registries of NCC-1017 and NCC-1371, respectively. Also, in ST6's Operation: Retrieve scene, there is listed the USS Eagle, NCC-956. I am not certain if this was shown to be Constitution-class or not, but the Star Trek Encyclopedia says it was. In addition, the Encyclopedia lists six additional Constitution-class ships w/ registry numbers lower than 1700. Obviously, something is amiss.

Theories abound that these early ships started out as one class and later were converted into Constitutions. Some of these involve the idea that the class name changes every time a significant upgrade is made (some people still think of the Constitution upgrade as Enterprise-class). Also, there is still nothing to say for absolute certain that registries are assigned chronologically (though I can't imagine why they would be assigned so unchronologically).

While there is really no evidence to conclusively refute these theories, I'd like to present an alternative - the NCC-1700 USS Constitution was not the class ship of the Constitution class. Rather, there was a USS Constitution before the 1700. It would have had a registry probably in the 900s, or, if you don't buy the Eagle bit, at most in the very early 1000s. It was destroyed sometime before 2245, when the second batch of Constitutions was launched (assuming there even was an entire batch all launched at once), so one of those ships was named in it's honor. This ship was the one with the registry NCC-1700, which happened to be presented in one of Scotty's tech manuals in "Space Seed."


Design of the Apollo-class

by "Vanguard"

The design of this vessel is under debate. The confusion stems from the SS T'Pau, mentioned and seen in "Redemption II" (TNG). The encyclopedia says this ship is an Apollo-class, and according to the encyclopedia entry for the T'Pau it was one of the three ships seen at the end of the episode. Hence, the Vulcan ship is now Apollo-class. Riker also asks Geordi if one of the three ships is the T'Pau, and Geordi replies that he does not know due to interference. Many take this that Riker saw the three ships and knew they were Apollo-class, and then he jumped to the conclusion that one of them might be the T'Pau.

Others argue that a strange saucer seen in "Emissary" (DS9) was the Gage, an Apollo class vessel, which cancels out the Vulcan vessel. Many also believe that since the Vulcan ships did not follow the traditional saucer and secondary hull form of Starfleet vessels, the T'pau can not be an Apollo-class vessel. There is also the chance that the Encyclopedia is wrong and that the T'pau is not Apollo-class at all. Another argument against the T'pau being one of the three ships at the end was the fact that it's deflector array was strewn across the cargo bay floor of the Enterprise. However, it is not known if the deflector is really needed at all to "fly" the ship, or if the deflector was later replaced.


Existence of the Yellowstone-class and Zodiac-class

by Bernd Schneider

The Yellowstone-class runabout was the ship Harry Kim was working on in a parallel reality ("Non Sequitur" (VOY)). The dialogues suggest that the design of the novel tetryon-plasma warp propulsion system was mainly his idea. Therefore it is improbable that someone else would have come up with the same idea while Harry was aboard Voyager in the Delta Quadrant. Considering the Yellowstone looks exactly like the Danube-class, this would be no great loss.

The USS Yorktown was mentioned in Q's projected future ("All Good Things" (TNG)), and the Encyclopedia states that the ship belongs to the Zodiac-class. Since there are no examples of Zodiac-class ships in the "real" world, it is not clear whether the class really exists. The registry NCC-61137 for the Yorktown suggests the class already existed in the 2360's. It is improbable that Q invented a class or a particular ship whose existence can easily be disproved in the present, unless this is supposed to be some kind of hint for the time-traveling Picard. We can't be sure about that, however. At least two other Federation ship classes from the future, the Olympic-class (Pasteur) and the Freedom-class (Concorde), do actually exist, so we might assume the same concerning the Zodiac.


Niagara-class Design

by Bernd Schneider

The Niagara-class USS Princeton is one of the 39 ships destroyed at Wolf 359. The fact that it is listed in official publications points to the existence of a studio model for this class; however, on-screen evidence is still missing. The Star Trek Fact Files depict an Ambassador-style ship with 3(!) Galaxy class nacelles as the official design for the Niagara class. While most people interested in starships agree this is one of the ugliest designs, there are two opinions concerning the credibility of the Fact Files schematics:

  1. The Fact Files are not exactly a canon publication, and as long as hard canon (on-screen) evidence is missing, no one has to believe what is printed.
  2. Most of the schematics in the Fact Files are reliable, and recently the one-nacelled Freedom-class seemed to be exactly as depicted.

At least the basic design could be correct, assuming the draftsman had some information on the studio model.


Nova-class

by Lee Kelly

In the Next Generation Technical Manual, a brief final section is given over to the design of ship that might one day replace the Galaxy-class starship. Given the operational lifetime of the Galaxy was estimated at more than a hundred years, one could assume that the class, called the Nova, would one day appear, but not in any of the current incarnations of Trek.

This has led to many amateur ship designers creating their own concepts of what the Nova might look like. Most of these were better than the meagre sketches in the TNGTM. However, several events have occurred to banish the Nova as we know it into oblivion:

  1. The steady erosion of the TNGTM's credibility as "canon."
  2. No mention in the TNGTM of the Sovereign-class, which while in no way meant to fulfill the duties of the Galaxy is similar enough to warrant notice. Of course, we know this is because when they wrote the TM they had no idea of what was going to happen, but the mere exclusion damns the book.
  3. Finally, a science vessel, the USS Equinox, has appeared on Voyager, and is now confirmed as being a Nova-class vessel developed and built in the early- to mid-2360s. Sadly, this last fact completely invalidates the Nova section in the TM.

Therefore, in order to retain this section as part of the Trek canon, one has to come up with a theory to explain what happened to the original Nova. Two likely ones are as follows:

  1. Someone liked the name and stole it for their science ship project, or used it in error.
  2. With the rollout of the Sovereign-class, its potential as an Explorer made the development of a Galaxy replacement unnecessary for the foreseeable future, and the Nova Project was instead rethought as a small science ship - to replace the Oberth class? To save further time, they might have also used the warp-tested Defiant Pathfinder spaceframe as their basic design.


Number of Galaxy-class ships

by Lee Kelly

Gene Roddenbery once remarked that only 12 Galaxy-class starships were built, due to the length of time taken for construction. The TNG Technical Manual repeats this, saying that only six were actually outfitted, while the remaining half-dozen hulls were mothballed for future use.

The known members of the class are as follows:

  • USS Galaxy, (NX)NCC-70637 (Destroyed/Damaged 2374)
  • USS Yamato, NCC-71807 (Destroyed 2364)
  • USS Enterprise, NCC-1701-D (Destroyed 2371)
  • USS Odyssey, NCC-71832 (Destroyed 2370)
  • USS Venture, NCC-71854
  • USS Trinculo, NCC-71867 (model seen only)
  • USS Challenger, NCC-71099

In addition, the names of USS Cortez and USS Magellan have been bandied about as possible Galaxies; plus two ships have been seen with the strange 'cobra-stripes' on the back of the saucer neck, which appeared on none of the above.

There is absolutely nothing to confirm the 12-ship hypothesis, and its proponents largely cling to it out of a faith in the words of Roddenbery. However, certain facts should be considered:

  1. Sacrifice of Angels (DS9): A large number of Galaxies appear in this battle, between 6 and 9. Given that 3 had been destroyed at this point, this could mean that every single remaining Galaxy was there! It's a nice idea, but hardly likely that ALL of them would gather for one battle.
  2. Galaxy Wings: These are referred to in "Sacrifice of Angels" as being subdivisions of the fleet, and one such is given the number 12. If a Galaxy Wing is based around the linchpin of a Galaxy-class starship, then there were in fact at least 12 present.
  3. Registry numbers: the class ship is lowest, as usual; then sometime after that there is the Yamato, which was the second built according to the TNGTM. This is part of a block of 4 with numbers very close together, which might make six. But there is also the Challenger with a very low registry (unless everyone read it wrong, and it was NCC-71899). This contradicts the whole six-ship hypothesis, unless we ignore the dubious Trinculo. But then wouldn't six ships show a regular separation of numbers?
  4. Is the Challenger 'real?' It's appearance is in a lost future, but it's early number means it must already exist. Maybe it's one of the six half-built Galaxies that were put in storage, which could have been given lower registries for some reason.
  5. At least two Galaxies are seen in Spacedock in 2371 at the Utopia Planitia Fleet Yards in Mars orbit - refit, repairs or new ships? We hear about new ships built at Utopia all the time, but never any refits there.


Reasons for retiring the Soyuz-class

by Chris Martin

The Soyuz-class was decommissioned earlier than the Miranda-class possibly because it's usefulness was no more. Soyuz-class ships may have been simply Mirandas modified for a specific purpose, with the additional sensor pods and cargo area. After X number of years, the ships were no longer needed, so they were decommissioned.

Another theory is that the Soyuz-class was merely a filler class for a new ship. Soyuz-class ships would be easy to build, using mostly Miranda components, and served in the role of the upcoming ships. Then, after the new class was finished, the Soyuz-class was abandoned and taken out of service.

Yet another possibility is that the Soyuz-class ships were retrofitted to the standard Miranda-class configuration, and continued in service as regular Mirandas.


Saucer Separation on the Excelsior-class

by Adam Heinbuch

Studio Model:

  • Watching Generations, especially on DVD, we get an excellent shot of the E-B's upper neck as it passes by the camera revealing the damage done by the Nexus. A close examination of the area where the 'neck' meets the saucer reveals many potential separation lines.
  • The design of the upper 'neck' area remained unchanged following the model's refitting to become the E-B, so this seems to suggest saucer separation abilities on the original Excelsior as well.

Literature:

  • The novelization of "Generations" includes a saucer separation simulation on board the Excelsior just before Sulu gets word of Kirk's death. Although certainly not canon, this is still an illustration of how such a procedure could work with an Excelsior-class.
  • The Encyclopedia (2nd edition) states that "earlier classes of ship were also capable of saucer separation, although not all were capable of reconnection afterward". This certainly could be interpreted as including the Excelsior.

Design Trends:

Looking at other examples of saucer separation on different classes of starship, we can see that virtually every ship with some sort of 'neck' between the saucer and secondary hull has saucer separation. The list of these classes includes:

  • Constitution (Original) - In the TOS episode "The Apple", Kirk tells Scotty to prepare for such a maneuver when the Enterprise was threatened by the God machine Vaal.
  • Constitution (Refit) - Early storyboards had the Enterprise separating the saucer after the destruction of V'ger to fight the Klingons V'ger had 'absorbed' at the beginning of the movie. This sequence was later discarded due to the high price to film it, but the separation elements were retained in the actual design and model.
  • Ambassador - Non-canon, but there's a rumour out there that this was the first ship to feature a reconnectable saucer separation, which makes sense, seeing how it would later become a primary feature of the Galaxy-class. The studio model certainly allows for this possibility, as well.
  • Galaxy - Everyone knows this. Although it was originally supposed to separate every time it went into battle, as to carry the civilians to safety, saucer separation was actually underutilized because it slowed the story down considerably (and no one liked the 'chicken with its head cut off' look of the secondary hull).
  • Sovereign - Although still non-canon, John Eave's sketches clearly show that the Sovereign-class does indeed have the ability to separate, and presumably reconnect as well. This class would mark a significant change in the trends, as it has separation capability without an actual 'neck' to speak of. Note: the Intrepid-class, also without a 'neck', does not separate. Hopefully, we may yet see the E-E separate in some future movie.

These examples are only of the most prominent classes in Starfleet.  Presumably, many other unseen ship classes also have saucer separation.

Conclusion:

Examining this evidence, it seems very reasonable to assume that the Excelsior-class, and its refitted variant type, do indeed possess saucer separation in some degree, most likely separation of the non-reconnectable variety.


Class of the USS Biko

by Frank Gerratana

The USS Biko appeared in "A Fistful of Datas" (TNG). The first edition of the Encyclopedia gives no class for the ship, and the second edition says that it's Olympic-class. However, the ship is clearly seen in the episode, and is in fact Oberth-class.


Class of the USS Brattain

by Frank Gerratana

We see the Miranda-class Brattain in "Night Terrors" (TNG). Both editions of the encyclopedia show this ship without a rollbar, but the rollbar is clearly visible in the episode.


Class of the USS Carolina

by Steve Pugh

The Encyclopedia lists this vessel as a Daedalus-class. This is impossible, as that class was retired some 70 years before the Carolina was supposed to be in service.

Unless, the Daedalus-class were retired as exploration vessels but continued in service as freighters. Unlikely; to me, retired means retired.

Or, the Klingons were dumb enough to send a fake distress call from a ship no longer in service. (One removed from service before the first contact between Klingons and the UFP?!) Again, unlikely.

So we can conclude that the Carolina is, to a high degree of probability, a not a Daedalus-class ship and that the Encyclopedia is incorrect.

(Additional non-canon information from the author of this article)


Class of the USS Centaur

by Lee Kelly

The USS Centaur was seen in the DS9 episode "A Time To Stand" where it was commanded by Captain Charlie Reynolds. The same officer, a friend of Sisko's, is mentioned again in "Sacrifice of Angels."

The Centaur seems to be constructed from an Excelsior saucer with certain additional protuberances on the underside, with a pair nacelles (which closely resemble those of an Excelsior turned sideways but with differences in details) in Miranda configuration attached by what appears to be an outsized (i.e., definitely not to scale) Miranda rollbar.

No class is specified, and no registry is visible, therefore the age of the ship is unknown. One point of view is that if there is a Mirandaised Excelsior then this it it. Another viewpoint says this is a kitbash in the tradition of the other ships in the DS9TM, one of which resembles this ship quite closely - with some telling differences such as the positioning of the nacelles. Points to note:

  1. The name 'centaur' refers to a mythical creature that is a hybrid of two other species. There is a mention in the Encyclopaedia of a Chim(a)era-class starship - could this be it? Maybe the imminent Encyclopedia update will confirm it once and for all.
  2. The appearance of the Centaur comes only 3 months into the war - could they have deployed 'kitbash' ships this early in the conflict? If so, Starfleet must have anticipated the losses they'd suffer.

So which is it? All together now: we don't know! I prefer to think of it as a proper class, maybe one of the ones we have heard of but never seen...the only thing to contradict this is a logical argument - why is there a kitbash in the DS9TM that looks so similar? If the components are nearly identical, then why not make a 'proper' Centaur-type ship?


Class of the USS Farragut

by Chris Holly

At the end of Generations, three starships arrive at Veridian III to rescue the Enterprise-D survivors. One of them is the Nebula-class USS Farragut (NCC-60597). This establishes that the Farragut was a Nebula-class starship.

The next time the Farragut is mentioned is in "Nor the Battle to the Strong" (DS9). Here, it is reported that the Farragut was destroyed by the Klingons in the Lambatta Cluster.

Now here's the problem. The Farragut is mentioned in another episode, "Chrysalis" (DS9). At the establishing shot, there is an Excelsior-class starship docked at Deep Space Nine. Some people believe that the Excelsior seen in this episode is the Farragut. If this is the case, then either Starfleet is still constructing Excelsiors or Starfleet pulled out an old Excelsior and renamed her Farragut. Other people believe that the Farragut was not seen in the episode. She simply delivered the Jack Pack and left on a mission only to return later to pick them up.

If the Farragut is Excelsior-class now, again, this means that either Starfleet is still constructing Excelsiors (which have served Starfleet for 80 years) or Starfleet plucked an old Excelsior and renamed it Farragut (but what is the reason for this?). But if the Farragut was not really the ship seen docked at Deep Space 9, why did the camera hang onto that Excelsior? That shot implies that the Farragut is Excelsior.


Class and Registry of the USS Melbourne

by Frank Gerratana

The USS Melbourne first appeared in the graveyard scene of "Best of Both Worlds" (TNG) as a Nebula-class study model. Its registry, NCC-62043, was not visible, nor has the location of the model even been positively identified. Nonetheless, in "Future Imperfect" (TNG), we see this model on Riker's "future" desk, including a plaque with this name and registry. Later, in "Emissary" (DS9), the Melbourne is shown as an Excelsior-class ship. The registry is unclear, but the Encyclopedia says that that it is indeed the same as the Nebula's, NCC-62043. Others say that the registry is NCC-3184x, but this cannot be the case, especially with the second digit.

Since this ship was seen clearly, the Melbourne is now "really" an Excelsior. The Nebula from "Best of Both Worlds" could easily be the Nebula-class Bellerephon, also destroyed at Wolf 359. Since the Melbourne model on Riker's desk existed only in a fantasy, one could say that around the time of "Future Imperfect," Riker was thinking about how the Melbourne's registry better fits a Nebula rather than an Excelsior (for example), and this thus manifested itself in the form of the model.


Class of the USS Potemkin

by Matt Dock

The USS Potemkin (NCC-18253) is listed in both Star Trek Encyclopedias as being an Excelsior-class starship. Though the Potemkin has on screen as an Excelsior-class in "Ethics" (TNG), there is a second sighting of her in the episode "Second Chances" (TNG). In the Enterprise-D's observation lounge, LaForge goes to one of the screens in the lounge to show the bridge crew what caused the duplicate Riker to appear. The screen shows the planet's surface, the two transporter beams which caused the mishap, and an Ambassador-class starship. Logically, one would assume that this is a representation of the USS Potemkin. But is this really what the Potemkin looks like? Some say the Ambassador class starship model is just a 'placeholder', or a generic design that shows the viewer that it's a Federation starship, not giving out many details. But, this screen could be showing the true USS Potemkin as an Ambassador-class vessel. The registry number of NCC-18253 fits into both class's numbering schemes, but there are no other Excelsior-class starships with numbers as 18xxx. The same applies for the Ambassador class. The possiblity of there being two USS Potemkins is unlikely, though, with the low registry on the Excelsior version, and whether or not Excelsiors are still being built.


Class of the SS Woden

by Bernd Schneider

The Woden is the unmanned freighter from "The Ultimate Computer" (TOS). Due to budget limitations of the 60's the studio model of Khan's Botany Bay was reused for this purpose. Is the Woden really a DY-100 class ship like the Botany Bay? The fact that the Botany Bay was still operational 270 years after it was launched suggests that it was a pretty good design. There are, however serious objections despite the screen evidence:

  1. The DY-100 is a ship design from the late 20th century without warp or even impulse drive. Maybe they have been completely rebuilt by 2268, but it's a bit like a wooden sailing ship in a modern navy, there is a point where the whole construction is inevitably useless.
  2. Most probably the ships of this class (built as early as 1996 in the Trek timeline) have not survived the Eugenic Wars and the Third World War.


[Main Page | Class-related Issues | Registries | Miscellaneous | FAQ]